Text version of the Militant, a socialist newspaper  
the Militant, a socialist newspaper
about this site directory of local distributors how to subscribe submit a photo or image order bundles of the Militant to sell
news articles editorials columns contact us search view back issues
The Militant this week
El Militante
Black farmers protest gov’t discrimination
Denied loans but determined to farm
Workers need labor party, say socialist candidates
Protests denounce FBI raids in Chicago and Minneapolis
‘I’ve never seen a history like this’
Washington launches Afghan assault, raids Pakistan border
3 White House economic aides quit amid ‘stimulus’ failures
Women’s liberation and the Cuban Revolution
Panel presentation held at library in Atlanta
Spelman students discuss cosmetics and exploitation
Record of Militant Fightning Fund
Click here for the record

A socialist newsweekly published in the interests of working people
Vol. 74/No. 38      October 11, 2010


Click here for Militant Labor Forums or for Calendar Events

(lead article)
Black farmers protest
gov’t discrimination
Denied loans but determined to farm
Militant/Nick Gruenberg
Black farmers and supporters in Washington September 23 protest government discrimination. Action was initiated by John Boyd, driving tractor, and Robert Binion, with megaphone.

WASHINGTON—Five dozen Black farmers and their supporters marched from the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to the Capitol September 23, demanding equal treatment and government compensation to settle a long-standing discrimination lawsuit.

Farmers came from Alabama, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Texas, Virginia, Kansas, and North Carolina, and were joined by supporters from the Washington area. The action was initiated by John Boyd, president of the National Black Farmers Association (NBFA), and Robert Binion, a 61-year-old peach farmer from Clanton, Alabama. Also participating in the protests was Lawrence Lucas, president of the USDA Coalition of Minority Employees, which supports the Black farmers’ fight.

“My father was a sharecropper,” said Lester Bonner, 63, a farmer from Dinwiddie, Virginia. “In 1987 my brother and I tried to get a $15,000 USDA loan so we could buy 138 acres our family owned back in 1893. The USDA said 'no' and we had to borrow the money from a friend. That’s how they treat us.”

“What they [USDA] have done to us is very wrong,” said Thomas Franklin, 71, from Marion, Alabama. He raises cattle, goats, and garden vegetables in Perry County on land that belonged to his father. Like many of those at the march, he is a veteran of both the civil rights movement and farmer protests.

“It’s harder now than ever for a Black farmer to get a loan from the USDA,” Franklin said. “You have to be a lawyer to fill out the application and you have to be a banker to get a loan. You have to have A1 credit, and if you’re Black, they still automatically say ‘no.’” Denied loans but determined to keep farming, Franklin simultaneously worked for 23 years as a union steelworker at the Empire Coke plant in Tuscaloosa and at other jobs.

Along with thousands of other Black farmers, Franklin filed a claim in the 1997 Pigford v. Glickman class-action lawsuit. That suit charged the USDA with decades of racist discrimination by denying Black farmers access to loans and other farm programs.

The 1999 consent decree settling Pigford v. Glickman promised a $50,000 payment—as well as loan forgiveness, tax breaks, and priority consideration for future loans—as long as farmers provided “substantial evidence” of discrimination.

Of the original 22,547 claims filed, 41 percent were denied. An additional 75,000 claims were turned down on the basis that farmers filed after a September 2000 deadline. Refusing to accept this situation, Black farmers have been fighting for more than a decade to extend compensation.

Finally, $100 million in additional funds was allocated in the 2008 Farm Bill. The Barack Obama administration requested an additional $1.15 billion, bringing the total to $1.25 billion. This was passed by the House of Representatives in May, but the Senate has repeatedly blocked release of the money.  
Sign an executive order!’
The day before the march a delegation of farmers met with Joe Leonard, head of the USDA Office of Civil Rights, and other USDA officials.

“We go to USDA offices today in Alabama and they refuse to give us loans,” Binion told the USDA staffers. “Not in 1986, but today… . Everybody is watching the USDA hang us, from the president on down, and they don’t do anything. Okay, now go to Obama and tell him to sign an executive order.”

“I have applied for loans many times and been denied,” added Willie James Brown, 79, from Marbury, Alabama, who farms 365 acres. “And you’ve always been denied?” asked Leonard pointedly. “I got a loan once 20 years ago,” Brown replied.

“Three out of the last four years, we’ve had floods,” said George Hildebrandt, from Leavenworth, Kansas, whose farm is on the Missouri River. His great-grandfather got the land in 1880 under the 1862 Homestead Act, which provided free land to those who wanted to farm after the Civil War.

“I’ve asked for loans to raise the levees to save my home, and they’ve denied me every time. You go into the office and it’s lily-white, and they look at you like you’re the janitor.”

In face of relentless questioning by the farmers, Leonard and other USDA officials responded that they had to have specifics. “You may have been discriminated against all your life,” said Leonard, “but we have to have the paperwork.”

Farmers also met September 22 with staff from the office of Sen. Blanche Lincoln, a Democrat from Arkansas who heads the Senate Agricultural Committee. “This fight has gone on for too long,” Binion told Lincoln’s staff. “If the Senate won’t pass the funding, why can’t Senator Lincoln and others who say they support us go to President Obama and ask him to sign an executive order?”  
Class at Bowie State
Farmer Thomas Franklin and Jesse Binion, son of Robert Binion, spoke to a rural sociology class at Bowie State University, a nearby historically Black college, the same day on the invitation of Professor Dorothy Fardan. Students listened with rapt attention as Franklin described the conditions facing sharecroppers like his father during the decades of segregation before the massive civil rights movement of the 1950s and ’60s—which he and many other Black farmers were part of—brought down Jim Crow in the South.

At a news conference outside the Capitol September 23, NBFA president John Boyd introduced Democratic senators Kay Hagan from North Carolina and Blanche Lincoln, who told marchers they, along with Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana, were going to introduce a “stand-alone” measure to pay farmers.

“Every Black person in this country is one or two generations away from farming,” Boyd said, thanking everyone for their participation. “We are going to finish this fight,” Robert Binion said before his bus headed back to Alabama. “Even if they pass the funding, we are not going to sleep until every Black farmer gets justice.”

Chris Hoeppner contributed to this article.

Printer logo 
Printer-friendly version of this article

Home | Text-version home