Text version of the Militant, a socialist newspaper 
the Militant Socialist newspaper
about this site directory of local distributors how to subscribe submit a photo or image order bundles of the Militant to sell
news articles editorials columns contact us search view back issues
SOCIALIST WORKERS CAMPAIGN
The Militant this week
FRONT PAGE ARTICLES
Strikes, street actions topple Yugoslav regime
Workers lead mobilizations that open up political space
 
Palestinian deaths mount in Israeli crackdown
 
Los Angeles bus strikers gain new support
 
Sales of new pamphlet are at center of sub drive
 
FEATURE ARTICLES
Eyewitness in Belgrade: workers lead revolt
 
U.S. bill on food, medicine does not ease Cuba embargo
 
Growers and unions in California debate 'guest worker' bill
 
forums
calendar
SUB DRIVE
Overall sales chart
Submit Letter to the editor
submit forum
submit to calendar


A socialist newsweekly published in the interests of working people
Vol. 64/No. 40October 23, 2000

 
Growers and unions in California debate 'guest worker' bill
(feature article)
 
BY BRIGITTE SEGUIN  
FRESNO, California--In late September the United States House Judiciary Committee voted 16 to 11 in favor of an agricultural guest workers bill that will be presented before the House and Senate for approval. This bill would allow growers in the United States to hire up to 1 million workers, mostly from Mexico, during the harvest season. Workers would be required to return to Mexico when the harvest is over.

The "guest worker" program has been dubbed the Agricultural Job Opportunity Benefits and Security Act of 1999. Introduced a year ago, it would provide legal status to the workers if they work at least five years as laborers in the fields. These workers would be guaranteed minimum wage, but it is not clear how the wages would be calculated.

An aspect of the debate on the bill has been whether or not employers should be required to provide housing to these workers. The employers claim that it is too costly and inefficient and they would prefer to give vouchers or some cash to them to get their own housing. But there is a housing shortage in many states, posing a crisis for agricultural and other workers.

This is not the first time that the big farmers and the U.S. government have supported such a program. A similar law was introduced under the bracero program in 1942 during the labor shortages caused by World War II. An agreement between the U.S. and Mexican governments allowed Mexican workers to come to the United States to work on farms and on railroads for temporary employment. This agreement was extended until 1964. Those programs made it harder for workers to unionize and to fight to improve their wages and working conditions because they are always under the threat of deportation.

This recent bill is supported by the California Farm Bureau Federation, the National Council of Agricultural Employers, and the governors of Arizona and New Mexico, as well as the Nisei Farmers League. It is opposed by the Farm Worker Justice Fund, Southwest Voter Registration Project, and United Farm Workers which have denounced this program as an "indentured servitude."

At a hearing of the House Committee on Agriculture in Woodland, California, last May, David Weiss, a supporter of this bill, testified on behalf of the California Pear Growers. Weiss said, "Unfortunately, most of this type of work does not appeal to the majority of Americans, regardless of the national unemployment rate. Growers must therefore look to Mexico for the workers we need to complete these tasks. Suffice it to say that were it not for our Mexican neighbors, pears and many other tree fruits would not be viable crops in California."

The unemployment rate in the Central Valley, the largest agricultural center in the country, is in double digits, one of the highest in the country. The big growers still complain about a shortage of labor, especially during the harvest. A large supply of labor works to the advantages of the growers who impose low wages and miserable conditions.

In the 20th U.S. Congressional District of California, which is in the San Joaquin Valley, from Fresno to Bakersfield, the candidates have opposite point of views. Richard Rodriguez, the Republican candidate, supports the plan, agreeing that there is a shortage of farm workers. Calvin Dooley, the Democratic candidate, opposes it because he claims that these workers would be responsible for a higher unemployment rate.

Ned Measel, the Socialist Workers candidate, sees this program as an attack on the working class in general. "This program allows the growers to create more divisions among working people by stipulating under the law that a category of workers has more limited rights. They can be deported any time and are forced to work only as field labor under increasingly harsh conditions. Every worker in this country must have the same rights and ability to seek employment where they choose," Measel said.

He added that the labor movement should fight for equal rights for all immigrants, with or without papers.

As part of his campaign, Measel visited with the Union of Sheepherders, an organization that started to organize shepherds five years ago. There are about 3,000 such workers who came to this country under the H-2A program, which allows sheep owners through the Western Ranchers Association to hire workers, mostly from Chile and Peru, on a three-year contract.

Ví ctor Flores, the president of the union, stated, "It used to be that when an employer was not satisfied with a worker they dropped them off in Bakersfield. They would frequently call the Immigration and Naturalization Service. The shepherd could then be deported. The organization," he continued, "has fought for shepherds who get injured on the job to get workers compensation and we are also going to several hearings to testify before the California Industrial Welfare Commission on the minimum wage." In California, these shepherds receive $900 per month, which comes out to between 96 cents and $1.12 per hour, Flores said, because they work from dawn to dusk, seven days a week with no days off.

In his visit, Measel also saw the typical living arrangements provided by the employers. Shepherds live in small campers next to the grazing flock where the air is thick with dust and flies. There is no electricity. The only source of water is a metal drum with a spigot that is replenished every three to four days. There is no bathroom. Several small propane tanks are the only source of fuel. And the workers are not permitted to leave the property. The Union of Shepherds, Measel said, is part of the rising resistance of workers and farmers around the United States. Measel called on the U.S. government to end all deportations and INS raids. "Workers from around the world have the right to come to the United States and to do so with equal rights and protections under the law. By opposing this bill and demanding equal rights for all immigrants, the labor movement can unify and strengthen the working class as a whole," he added.

 
 
 
Front page (for this issue) | Home | Text-version home