The Militant(logo) 
    Vol.62/No.47           December 28, 1998 
 
 
Letters  
Facts on West Papua
There is an error in the "In Brief" item of the December 14 issue, "Indonesian troops massacred W. Papua independence fighters."

The item says that "Biak residents held a festival commemorating the July 1, 1961, proclamation of West Papuan independence from New Guinea."

West Papua was still a Dutch colony at that time, with UN- sponsored "decolonization" in the process of handing the territory over to Indonesia against the wishes of the people. The Indonesian administration was established in 1963 and, in 1969, with a UN-endorsed "act of free choice," which West Papuans bitterly describe as the "act of no choice," was incorporated into Indonesia. The Free West Papua (OPM) movement declared independence from Indonesia in 1971.

In any case, "New Guinea" has never been a country to declare independence from!

Bob Aiken

Sydney, Australia

Reaction to Buchanan
Enclosed are two pieces taken from the Philadelphia Inquirer. The first is a column by Patrick J. Buchanan, where he demands that Harvard University accept white Christians to its student body at a rate of 75 percent, and no less. The next piece is a series of letters to the Inquirer which are for the most part critical of Buchanan's column.

For anyone familiar with Buchanan's politics, this column should be no surprise. However, I found this piece a bit more reprehensible than most of his columns and so did many of the readers of the Inquirer.

In Daniel Guerin's book Fascism and Big Business, he pointed out how the Nazis wanted to push social relations back to a time before the revolutions against feudalism. This was their theoretical basis for a complete autocracy. Buchanan not only wants to push us back to before the Civil Rights movement, he wants to go back to before the American Revolution. After all, the First Amendment of the Constitution is freedom of religion.

Steve Halpern

Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

 
 
 
Front page (for this issue) | Home | Text-version home